IP
Super Smash Bros. Controversy: Ludwig’s Legal Tangle with Nintendo
Popular gaming YouTuber Ludwig Ahgren, commonly known as Ludwig, recently found himself in a legal quagmire with Nintendo. The gaming giant sent him what he describes as a “baby cease-and-desist” letter, sparking a significant discussion in the esports community.
The Cease-and-Desist Saga
Ludwig’s troubles began when he considered modifying Nintendo’s iconic game, Super Smash Bros. Melee, for a tournament he was organizing. The proposed changes to the game’s Pokémon Stadium stage would prevent it from undergoing random transformations. However, Nintendo was quick to respond, sending Ludwig a Notice of Infringement of Intellectual Property. This formal document indicated that Ludwig was using the company’s intellectual property without the necessary permissions.
Nintendo’s New Tournament Restrictions
Adding fuel to the fire, Nintendo recently introduced a series of stringent restrictions for Super Smash Bros. tournaments. These rules mandate that tournaments can have no more than 200 participants, a prize pool capped at USD 5,000, no sponsors, and must use an unaltered version of the game. Larger commercial tournaments require a special license from Nintendo. These changes have left many in the community concerned about the future of Super Smash Bros. in the esports arena.
Past Tensions with the Smash Community
This is not the first time Nintendo has been at odds with the Super Smash Bros. community. Last year, a significant dispute arose between the company and professional players over the canceled Smash World Tour event. The tension escalated to the point where some began boycotting events associated with Nintendo-partnered organizations.
Ludwig’s Perspective
In a video titled “I Got Sued by Nintendo,” Ludwig delved deeper into his legal encounter with the company. He highlighted the modifications he intended for the Super Smash Bros. Melee’s Pokémon Stadium stage and expressed his understanding of the notice as a milder form of a cease-and-desist letter. Ludwig’s main contention was that instead of an outright ban, Nintendo wanted him to adhere to their rules.
Community Reactions
Ludwig’s video garnered significant attention, amassing over 430 comments in less than an hour. The community’s reactions were mixed, with some criticizing Nintendo for being a “petty company” and others questioning the legality of the gaming giant’s imposed restrictions.
Conclusion
While the future of Super Smash Bros. tournaments remains uncertain, one thing is clear: the love for the game remains undiminished. As pro player Joseph “Mang0” Marquez aptly put it, “I’ll play Melee in my mind… we’ll play [it] in a garage.”
Image source: Ludwig Ahgren via Twitter
